The Octagon has witnessed countless tales of triumph and grit, but few resonate as profoundly as the recent retirement of Dustin “The Diamond” Poirier. Following his valiant, albeit ultimately unsuccessful, trilogy bout against Max Holloway at UFC 318 in his home state of Louisiana, Poirier symbolically left his gloves in the center of the cage, signaling the end of an era. Just days removed from this emotional farewell, the Louisiana native has begun to reflect on a career defined by relentless forward pressure, a granite chin, and an unwavering commitment to exciting fights. Amidst the introspection, one question always lingers for any retiring legend: what if?
The Unfought Dream: Poirier`s Illustrious Wish List
Despite a schedule that reads like a `who`s who` of mixed martial arts elite, Poirier recently revealed a short, yet significant, list of opponents he wished he could have squared off against before hanging up his gloves. Appearing on `The Ariel Helwani Show,` Poirier named three distinct legends: BJ Penn, Donald “Cowboy” Cerrone, and Nate Diaz.
His reasoning for including BJ Penn speaks volumes about the reverence a new generation of fighters holds for the sport`s pioneers. “Growing up I thought BJ Penn was the best lightweight ever,” Poirier stated. This sentiment echoes through the MMA community, acknowledging Penn`s near-mythical status as a two-division champion and a fighter who famously took on all comers, often outside his natural weight class. The idea of a prime Penn, “The Prodigy” known for his unparalleled jiu-jitsu and striking fluidity, meeting a modern powerhouse like Poirier is, admittedly, an irresistible thought experiment. It`s a clash across eras, a hypothetical battle that could only exist in the imaginations of fight fans, given Penn`s 2015 Hall of Fame induction and his official retirement.
The inclusion of Donald “Cowboy” Cerrone also highlights a peculiar gap in Poirier`s extensive resume. Both men were stalwarts of the lightweight division for years, known for their high-volume striking and willingness to engage in wars. “I’m surprised me and [Donald Cerrone] never fought,” Poirier mused. It`s a fight that seemed destined to happen multiple times given their parallel careers and mutual reputation for delivering fireworks. Fate, however, often intervenes in the intricate dance of fight matchmaking, leaving fans to ponder what might have been a striking clinic.
Finally, Nate Diaz rounds out the list. The Stockton native, infamous for his iron will and unyielding style, has long been a potential opponent for Poirier, with their paths nearly crossing on several occasions. “Nate Diaz, obviously, it was close a few times,” Poirier confirmed. A bout between “The Diamond” and Diaz promised unadulterated chaos, a high-octane affair driven by both men`s refusal to take a backward step. The narrative writes itself: two durable, fan-favorite sluggers squaring off. The fact it never materialized leaves a palpable sense of unfinished business for the fans, if not for Poirier himself.
A Legacy Undiminished by Unfought Foes
Despite these handful of “what ifs,” Poirier remains resolute about his career`s trajectory. “Besides that, I fought the best of my era. I can sit back and say ‘I fought the best guys in the world at my weight class’.” This assertion is not hyperbole. Poirier`s resume is studded with victories over legends such as Conor McGregor (twice), Justin Gaethje, and Eddie Alvarez. He also faced the undisputed titans of the lightweight division, including Islam Makhachev, Khabib Nurmagomedov, and Charles Oliveira – challenges that, while resulting in losses, cemented his status as a true championship contender willing to test himself against anyone.
His recent reflection on his final fight further underlines the profound nature of his retirement. During his appearance on `The Bohnfire` podcast, Poirier revealed a surprising shift in his mindset during the UFC 318 encounter. For the first time in his career, he approached a fight with a “self-preservation” focus. This newfound perspective, born perhaps from years of absorbing punishment and pushing physical limits, reportedly affirmed his decision to step away. While there were claims from others, including former UFC champion Aljamain Sterling, that Max Holloway “pulled back” on punches in the opening round, Poirier`s own internal shift speaks volumes about the physical and mental toll of a career at the sport`s summit.
The Diamond`s Shining Farewell
Dustin Poirier`s career is a testament to perseverance, skill, and an undeniable warrior spirit. He has left an indelible mark on the UFC, not just through his highlight-reel knockouts and relentless pace, but through his integrity and willingness to face anyone. His “wish list” of opponents isn`t a sign of regret, but rather a final, respectful nod to the sport`s history and its diverse pantheon of legends. As “The Diamond” rides off into the sunset, his legacy is secure, shining brightly as one of the most exciting and respected competitors to ever grace the Octagon.
